The Mueller report – it all began with the FBI in an impossible position in 2016


The Mueller report on alleged collusion between the Trump campaign and the Russian government is with the US Justice Department.  The Attorney-General (with every degree of plausibility) says that there is no case to answer on the main charge.

Do we know who has won and whether it matters?

In an environment where the middle ground has narrowed to vanishing point, it looks like a big victory for Trump.  His opponents had charged him with quasi-treason. The charges could not be sustained.  Their over-reach raises questions about their judgment and sustains Trump’s narrative that political and media elites are out to get him.

The half of the country that is sympathetic to Trump has been given a reminder of why they might want to support him for re-election in 2020.

But Trump’s opponents, while disappointed, will not feel defeated.  As the prosecutions to date have shown, this affair has provided plenty of examples of unsavory and unedifying behaviour in the Trump campaign and administration.  These will not make for pretty viewing when the detail of the Mueller report becomes more widely available and will help sustain anti-Trump fervour.

For those interested in at least attempting a wider perspective, your correspondent recommends the article ‘The Barr Letter Interlude’ by Yuval Levin in the National Review. ,  It has the following summary:

“And yet, much indignation—by Trump and by others—is justified by the nature of the investigation and especially by how it began. 

“The FBI found itself in an impossible situation in 2016, faced with two major-party nominees who both seemed like unprecedented national-security risks—the one having broken the laws that govern the management of classified information and the other enveloped in a semi-criminal network of corrupt fixers with bizarre foreign links.

“There were no real precedents to follow, and no way to proceed that could be fair to the candidates and so also to the next president. The agency then made matters worse by assigning to the investigation some people who clearly detested and looked down on Trump, and otherwise behaving unprofessionally.”

If you reject this framing, you have probably chosen one side or the other.

If you accept it, then ask yourself, with the full benefit of hindsight:  what was the ‘right‘ way to proceed in this situation?

And think:  what would have been required to secure tacit consent from both factions that such rules of the game were fair?

This is one of the hardest and most necessary tasks in a society governed by consent.  In the absence of that common ground, the Russia collusion affair will most likely end up a symbol for what each faction dislikes most about the other.



3 thoughts on “The Mueller report – it all began with the FBI in an impossible position in 2016

  1. The ‘right’ thing to do was to have people of integrity in the DOJ and the FBI handling the case. Which is why there now should be an investigation into the corruption in those organisations and how false doculments were used before a FISA court. If as you say both candidates were ‘suspect’ then why was the other not investigated after all the things that she did?

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I agree that the right thing to have done was to follow normal procedure and investigate without fear nor favour. Based on publically available information Clinton and her cohorts were treated much more leniently than they should gave been.
    Trump? Well, there is no evidence he did anything illegal. He’s a horrible man in many respects but I’m not sure the FBI had any reason to investigate him.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Didn’t it all begin with a certain dossier compiled by a former MI6 officer named Steele incorporating salacious information allegedly from Russian sources and paid for by Hillary Clinton? Shouldn’t the Clinton campaign have been investigated for collusion with the Russians via a number of middlemen? Maybe that will happen now along with much else. Trump has his personal failings but at least he’s kept his hands off the interns and is actually delivering on his promises.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.