Tax Freedom Day is being celebrated today – but the Taxpayers Union says we should wait a few weeks

Americans celebrated it on April 16.  New Zealand is celebrating it today, although the Taxpayers’ Union says this is a few weeks too soon.

We refer to Tax Freedom Day, when the nation as a whole has earned enough money to pay its total tax bill for the year.

For the rest of the year every cent we earn goes into our own pockets. Whoopee.

Each year, accounting and business advisory firm Baker Tilly Staples Rodway calculates Tax Freedom Day, the date when all our taxes are theoretically paid and every cent we earn for the rest of the year goes into our own pockets.

In 2018, the actual day fell on May 10, three days later than originally forecast, because GDP of $274 billion was lower than the expected $282 billion.

The latest numbers show Tax Freedom Day has been pushed back around five days since the Labour Government took control of the purse strings.

This is not because of any significant tax increases, but because while tax paid has increased in line with prior years, GDP has not grown at the same rate, Mike Rudd, tax director at Baker Tilly Staples Rodway, said in a press statement.

New Zealanders actually have a lower tax burden than many other countries in the OECD, particularly in the European Union, who are more relaxed about taxing to provide government services,hesaid.

This year the UK falls on May 29 (slightly earlier than last year), with France trailing on July 27, along with many other members of the EU. In the US, it’s Trump’s tax cuts that have helped shift its date back to April 16 – far earlier than its typical date around the first week of May. However, this impressive performance is only possible because the US continues to borrow heavily, racking up a trillion US dollars per annum in new debt.

Rudd noted:
  • We traditionally compare ourselves to Australia, but their means-tested superannuation generally means the country’s welfare bill is proportionally lower than New Zealand’s, one of the reasons it celebrates tax freedom sooner, on April 17. Bracket creep has been blamed for Australia’s Tax Freedom Day this year falling a day later than last year.
  • The spectre of “bracket creep” continues to push the tax total up for New Zealanders too, with income tax revenues rising six per cent on last year. As salaries creep up, a higher proportion of Kiwis move into the next tax band, even though some of the wage increase has merely been keeping pace with cost of living increases. The Tax Working Group recommended various adjustments to the tax thresholds but nothing to specifically address this issue.
  • Local government tax revenues nationwide are up nearly 9 per cent on last year, including regional fuel taxes of around $78 million collected by Auckland Council in the first six months since the tax was introduced in July 2018.

“The spike in council revenues really stands out this year. This represents a higher financial burden on businesses and ratepayers, which is concerning. On the other hand, thanks to revenue such as Auckland’s regional fuel tax being spent in a more targeted way on transport infrastructure and road safety, the regions could benefit faster than from more general taxation,” says Rudd.

National excise revenues are also up 7 per cent, mainly due to the nationwide fuel tax introduced in September.

Rudd says it is difficult to pinpoint exactly how the Tax Working Group’s recommendations and most notably capital gains tax proposals would have impacted on our Tax Freedom Days in the future, especially as these were intended to be part of a fiscally-neutral package.

In theory, the proposed tax relief measures, including a reduction in some rates and adjustments to the lower tax bands, could have pulled the date forward. Now that a capital gains tax has been rejected, along with the proposals for amending personal tax rate bands for those earning less than $70,000, the remaining 97 Tax Working Group proposals are unlikely to have a significant effect going forward.

“The rejection of CGT will make the upcoming ‘Wellbeing Budget’ particularly interesting, and the question is whether this will require much extra funding and, if so, where will that come from?” Rudd says.

The calculations used for New Zealand’s Tax Freedom Day are the same as those used around the world by bodies such as the Centre for Independent Studies in Australia and the Tax Foundation in the United States, and the same that Baker Tilly Staples Rodway has been using for over 20 years. The global standard does not include government spending.

But the Taxpayers Union claims Baker Tilly Stables Rodway is celebrating prematurely. 

Union economist Joe Ascroft reckons their calculations ignore the cost of debt-funded government spending and revenue gathering that falls outside the tax system.

Tax Freedom Day is in a few weeks’ time: on Saturday 1 June, he pronounced.

“OECD figures show that general government total outlays are equivalent to 41.573% of the economy. The implication is that until June 1, taxpayers are working for the Government – whether the Government is spending from their paycheque, or simply handing them a credit card already loaded up with debt.”

But ACT Leader David Seymour isn’t waiting.  He issued a press statement which said the tax burden has steadily increased under Labour, making New Zealand a less attractive place to live and work than Australia.  

“This gap could grow with both major parties in Australia promising tax relief if they win the election,” he declared.

He noted that Tax Freedom Day has fallen falls five days later this year than in 2017, when Labour took office, because the tax take has grown faster than the economy.

“Tax Freedom Day is also later in New Zealand than in the US and Australia because our tax burden is greater than our competitors.

“We have a highly progressive income tax system in which the top rate is three times the bottom rate.

“At present, 5 per cent of New Zealanders pay a third of income tax and fifty per cent pay just 8 per cent.

“Our corporate tax rate is uncompetitive at 28 per cent, significantly higher than the OECD average of 22 per cent.

“While taxes grow under Labour, National has vowed to effectively maintain the status quo if they return to Government.

ACT believes New Zealanders should pay low, flat taxes through a simple tax system that rewards success and promotes growth.

 

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.